The Imaam said, “It is not allowed for us to
take a specific person to be an Imaam and not benefit from the knowledge of
others because the truth which Allaah تبارك وتعالى revealed to His Prophet ﷺ is
not restricted to being found in one man after him ﷺ.
We do not believe about the Companions who
succeeded him ﷺ what the Shee’ah believe
about ’Ali ibn Abi Taalib, [i.e.,] that all of the knowledge which the
Prophet ﷺ had in his chest was transferred to
’Ali, we do not believe this, for this reason they believed him to be
infallible and held him to be like the Prophet ﷺ in
terms of infallibility.
We say: the knowledge which was in the
Prophet’s chest ﷺ was transferred to the Companions—not just one Companion—for
this reason, whoever wants to gain knowledge or gain an abundant portion of
it cannot do so from only one person, rather he must benefit from all of
them, for if not, he will have forfeited a great deal of it.”
Al-Hudaa wan-Noor, 101.
http://shaikhalbaani.wordpress.com
Questioner: What is your Eminence’s opinion about
relying on what al-Albaani has authenticated?
The Imaam of Ahlus-Sunnah, Ibn Baaz: Shaikh Muhammad Naasirud-Deen al-Albaani,
Naasirud-Deen al-Albaani, is from the elite, from the scholars well-known for
their integrity, sound ’aqidah, and diligence in authenticating hadiths
and clarifying their status. He is a chief support/pillar in this regard, but
he is not infallible, he may fall into a mistake in declaring some hadiths
authentic or weak, just like any other scholar, every scholar is like that,
having some mistakes, from the earliest scholars to those who came later.
The student of knowledge must look at what
he has authenticated, or declared hasan or weak, if he is from the
people of knowledge, from the people of this field, someone who knows hadiths
and can take a look at their paths of narration and their narrators, such
that if he finds that what the Shaikh has said is correct, then alhamdulillaah,
and if not then he relies on the proofs that are clear to him which the
people of knowledge in this field have followed. Because the people of
knowledge established principles to authenticate hadiths and declare
them weak, as for [… unclear …] the people of knowledge, he [i.e.,
al-Albaani] is a chief support/pillar in authenticating and declaring hadiths
to be weak, because he is from the people of knowledge, he is from those who
are [experts] in this field, he has studied for a long time and many years,
we ask Allaah to give us and him success and a good ending.
Questioner: Ameen, O Allaah, and may Allaah reward you with good.
See here
for a collection of statements that scholars made about Shaikh al-Albaani,
may Allaah have mercy on him.
|
The Imaam said, “So a Muslim individual’s
following a scholar, not going to anyone else except him, as though he is the
Lord of the Worlds who has the right to legislate—no one from mankind has
this right whatsoever, even the Prophet ﷺ
would relate what was revealed to him from his Lord.”
Al-Hudaa wan-Noor, 101.
|
|
http://backtosalafiyyah.blogspot.in/2015/07/some-differences-in-fiqhi-issues-imam.html
ReplyDelete